Our Mission is to keep our audience with an interrupted stream of financial information from serious sources, with the objective to provide the tools and sufficient knowledge about investments in the financial markets. we inform you, for example, CNBC, The Guardian, Washington Post, New York Times Selected News, selected financial news and videos, the Fed, FDIC, SEC, FTC press releases and enforcement actions.
Hot Topics | | Bond yields are back at record lows – why are investors so scared?
By: John Stepek
day, MoneyWeek's executive editor John Stepek and guest contributors
explain how current economic and political developments are affecting
the markets and your wealth, and give you pointers on how you can
profit. Sign up free here.
In July 2016, bond yields across the globe hit what I thought would prove to be their nadir.
It seems that I was wrong.
The yield on ten-year German bunds has, almost literally as
I type this, slid below the depths it last plumbed in the wake of the
So what’s going on?
Germany is particularly vulnerable to a global trade crash
In July 2016, the ten-year German bund yield fell to
negative 0.19%. In other words, investors were paying the German
government for the privilege of lending to it (to be fair, investors in
Swiss debt were paying a lot more).
For a long time, it looked as though that was the low.
Investors didn’t like the idea of Brexit, but they were growing less
concerned about a blow-up in the eurozone, and the US – while distracted
by bad-tempered electioneering – was doing well economically.
And yet, this morning, we’re back where we were in July
2016. In fact, we’re even lower. German bund yields are at their lowest
level since at least 1990, according to Bloomberg. The Daily Telegraph
goes a little further with a headline that says they haven’t been this
low in 700 years, although I’m not entirely sure where that analysis
Anyway, the point is – they’re at fresh record lows. That’s not a good sign, however you frame it.
So what’s going on?
There are elements of
this story that are unique to Germany and the eurozone. Bond yields in
the US have fallen too, but they’re not yet back at record lows. Let’s
look at those first.
Firstly, remember that the European Central Bank (ECB) is
maintaining current levels of quantitative easing (QE). In other words,
while it’s not growing its balance sheet, it’s not shrinking it either.
That means that when a bond matures, it needs to use the proceeds to buy
another to replace it.
This, notes Marcus Ashworth on Bloomberg, is “a key factor
in why German ten-year benchmark bonds have negative yields again… When
yields are this minuscule, even the ECB’s reinvestment of the money from
maturing bonds… has a disproportionate effect on prices. It means
there’s little left to satisfy demand once the central bank has done its
In other words, there’s lots of demand and supply – even
although there’s plenty of it, it’s not as though eurozone countries
aren’t issuing debt – can’t keep up.
Secondly, Germany is particularly vulnerable to
protectionism and its effect on global trade. One reason the record has
been hit again this morning is because of the news that Donald Trump has
just slapped a 5% tariff on all Mexican imports.
The move will start from 10 June. Trump says he wants
Mexico to take more action to stem illegal immigration. He also says
that the tariffs will climb by 5% a month until 1 October, when they’ll
be at 25%.
This introduces a new level of uncertainty into trade. The
US and Mexico seemed to have been getting along better as recently as
earlier this month, after the US dropped tariffs on steel and aluminium
products from Mexico and Canada, after renegotiating the NAFTA trade
Markets had rather started to assume that maybe Trump was
concentrating on dealing with China first. But if he can multitask – if
he can just wake up and decide to slap tariffs on Mexico for a non-trade
related reason – then that just reawakens all of those fears about
turning his sights on car manufacturing in Europe, for example.
In short, a more protectionist world hits export-reliant
economies hardest in the first instance. So this is particularly bad
news for Germany (although it’s pretty bad all round as far as I can
see). Indeed, it’s bad for the eurozone in general.
So there are elements of this that are eurozone specific.
How a deflation scare could be followed by an inflation shock
However, while it would be nice to brush it off as a local disturbance, that’s just not possible.
Yields might not be at record lows in the US, but they have
fallen hard in the last few months. Same goes for the UK. So what does
Put simply, investors are scared that there’s going to be a
recession. As a result, they’re betting that interest rates will have
to fall or money printing will have to restart. Therefore, why not own
bonds? After all, equities won’t do much for your in a recession as
corporate earnings collapse.
You can see the logic. The risk of a protectionist spiral
is starting to look quite real. The current expansion is long in the
tooth – they might not die of old age, but someone usually finds a way
to kill them eventually. A recession is only a matter of time. That’s
how cycles work.
And yet, I’m still not entirely convinced that it makes sense for bond yields to be sitting where they are.
Here’s a worrying thought. We all agree that populations
are feeling restive. They’re not satisfied with the quality of
leadership being shown by our politicians. They want change. They are
happy to at least contemplate radical ideas and policies.
This is happening at a time of full or near-full employment
around the globe. So it’s happening at a time where most people’s
individual economic circumstances are acceptable, and full-on economic
hardship is limited to a relative minority.
What happens if we get a recession, and unemployment starts
to rise? Does protectionism become more, or less, popular? Do demands
for “money printing for the people” grow louder or drop in volume?
It’s pretty obvious. And the thing is, both protectionism
and money printing for the people (rather than financial institutions),
We’ve been so long without inflation that we seem to have
forgotten that a recession can go hand in hand with rising prices – it’s
short, I can see why bond yields are sliding, and I increasingly think
that markets are right to be worried. But I can see a deflationary scare
being followed rapidly by an inflationary wake-up call.