Translate

Search This Blog

Search Tool




Oct 5, 2018

Stock Pickers Are Getting Trampled by the Bull Market I Investopedia News


Mark Kolakowski


As the result of rising interest rates, increased volatility, growing fears of an economic downturn, and escalating trade conflict, 2018 should have set the stage for active investment managers to shine, by using their savvy to exploit temporary pricing anomalies among individual securities in the markets. Instead, passively-managed index funds have increased their performance advantage from 2017 to 2018, The Wall Street Journal reports, as summarized in the table below.
Stock Pickers Are Losing Ground
Time Period % of Active Funds Beating Passive Funds
YTD 2018, Through June 30 36%
Full Year 2017 43%
Source: Morningstar Inc., as reported by The Wall Street Journal
Morningstar's analysis covered U.S. stock funds. Passively-managed funds include both index mutual funds and ETFs.

Significance for Investors

“It’s been a tough run” for U.S. equity managers, as Timothy McCusker, chief investment officer (CIO) at Boston-based investment consulting firm NEPC told the WSJ. "We expect active managers to underperform in euphoric markets. We're in the late stage of a market where fundamentals are being less rewarded," he added. The main reasons for the growing performance gap between active and passive funds in 2018 are presented in the table below.
Why Stock Pickers Are Getting Trampled
Active managers underperform in euphoric markets
Late bull market overlooks fundamentals
Growth stocks beating value stocks
Small number of big tech companies are driving the indexes
Momentum rules the market
Long-term cost and performance advantages of passive investing
Source: The Wall Street Journal
"Passive investing has worked so well because of the dominance of growth stocks in the indices," McCusker also observed. "Growth can win for a long time, but the tide can turn," he continued. In 2017, value investing was one of the few areas where a majority of active managers beat their benchmark indexes. Critics were quick to add that value stocks, and thus value indexes, performed poorly in 2017, and thus set a low bar to hurdle. (For more, see also: Stock Pickers Are Shining Amid Market Turmoil.)
Index mutual funds and passive index-linked ETFs have enjoyed explosive growth for two principal reasons: lower overall cost, and the fact that, historically, very few active investment managers and financial advisors have been able to beat the market consistently, if ever. Among the highest profile advocates of passive investing for these reasons is Vanguard Group founder Jack Bogle. Meanwhile, costs are being pushed down yet more, as leading sponsors of passive funds engage in a price war, per the WSJ. (For more, see also: Why Your Passive Fund Is Crushing Active Managers.)
Given that gains in the capitalization-weighted indexes have been propelled by a small number of giant tech companies, this has produced another disadvantage for active managers with diversified portfolios. For example, Amazon.com Inc. (AMZN), Apple Inc. (AAPL) and Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) were the biggest contributors to the total return for the S&P 500 Index (SPX) in the year ended June 30, contributing one-quarter of gains, according to data from S&P Dow Jones Indices, as cited by the WSJ.

Looking Ahead

As noted above, this year supposedly offered ideal conditions for active managers to prove their worth. Instead, they are trying to explain away another year of underperformance. The experience of 2018 suggests that investors must look more closely than ever in choosing among active managers. However, as the old disclaimer warns, past performance is not indicative of future results.
Regarding passive index-linked investing, the experience of 2018 also should illustrate how this may offer less diversification than meets the eye. The reason, as discussed above, is the huge influence that a few mega-cap stocks can exert on the major indexes.
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Top 3 Oil and Gas Penny Stocks for 2018

    The drop in oil prices has created penny stocks in the oil and gas industry.
  2. Investing

    3 Best Coffee Stocks for 2018

    Market watchers are predicting a jump in coffee in the next 12 months. If java's your morning jam, try these top coffee stocks.
  3. Insights

    Wal-Mart's New Advertising Plans

    Wal-Mart has a newly appointed chief marketing officer and a new chief customer officer while online advertising comes into focus.
  4. Investing

    3 Social Media Networks Before Facebook

    The social media environment had some interesting upstarts before Facebook. They eventually failed to achieve much, leaving room for Facebook to soar.
  5. Insights

    Can A Family Survive On The U.S. Minimum Wage? (WMT, COST)

    As the political debate roars on, the numbers are clear: Even two full-timers at U.S. minimum wage can't keep a family of four above the poverty line.
  6. Investing

    Musk Takes a Shot at SEC Days After Settlement

    Just days after settling with the SEC following his now infamous tweet about taking Tesla private, Musk took to twitter to mock the regulator.
  7. Investing

    Making Sense of the Euro - Swiss Franc (EUR/CHF) Relationship

    There is a strong correlation between the euro and Swiss franc (EUR/CHF) currency pair. Find out what it means for forex traders.
  8. Investing

    Berkshire Hathaway Stock Prices

    Learn how much you would now have if you had invested right after Berkshire Hathaway's IPO, and find out the classes of shares that you could invest in.
  9. Investing

    If You Had Invested Right After Tesla's IPO

    Find out how much you would have earned if you had invested in Tesla, Inc. right after its initial public offering, or IPO.
  10. Investing

    Top 4 Financial Stocks for 2018