(Doug Chayka/For The Washington Post)
In
May 1984, an official from the Trump Organization called to tell me how
rich Donald J. Trump was. I was reporting for the Forbes 400, the
magazine’s annual ranking of America’s richest people, for the third
year. In the previous edition, we’d valued Trump’s holdings at $200
million, only one-fifth of what he claimed to own in our interviews.
This time, his aide urged me on the phone, I needed to understand just
how loaded Trump really was.
The official was John Barron — a name we now know as
an alter ego of Trump himself.
When I recently rediscovered and listened, for first time since that
year, to the tapes I made of this and other phone calls, I was amazed
that I didn’t see through the ruse: Although Trump altered some cadences
and affected a slightly stronger New York accent, it was clearly him.
“Barron” told me that Trump had taken possession of the business he ran
with his father, Fred. “Most of the assets have been consolidated to Mr.
Trump,” he said. “You have down Fred Trump [as half owner] . . . but I
think you can really use Donald Trump now.” Trump, through this
sockpuppet, was telling me he owned “in excess of 90 percent” of his
family’s business. With all the home runs Trump was hitting in real
estate, Barron told me, he should be called a billionaire.
At
the time, I suspected that some of this was untrue. I ran Trump’s
assertions to the ground, and for many years I was proud of the fact
that Forbes had called him on his distortions and based his net worth on
what I thought was solid research.
But it
took decades to unwind the elaborate farce Trump had built to project an
image as one of the richest people in America. Nearly every assertion
supporting that claim was untrue. Trump wasn’t just poorer than he said
he was. Over time I have learned that he should not have been on the
first three Forbes 400 lists at all. In our first-ever list, in 1982, we
included him at $100 million, but Trump was actually worth roughly $5
million — a paltry sum by the standards of his super-monied peers — as a
spate of government reports and books showed only much later.
Phone conversation between Jonathan Greenberg and 'John Barron' (Donald Trump) on May 17, 1984. (Jonathan Greenberg)
The White House declined to comment for this story. The Trump Organization did not respond to a request for comment.
I
was a determined 25-year-old reporter, and I thought that, by reeling
Trump back from some of his more outrageous claims, I’d done a public
service and exposed the truth. But his confident deceptions were so big
that they had an unexpected effect: Instead of believing that they were
outright fabrications, my Forbes colleagues and I saw them simply as
vain embellishments on the truth. We were so wrong.
This was a model Trump would use for the rest of his career, telling a lie so cosmic that people believed that some kernel
of it had to be real. The tactic landed him a place he hadn’t earned on
the Forbes list — and led to future accolades, press coverage and
deals. It eventually paved a path toward the presidency.
*** *** *** ***
Malcolm Forbes came up with the idea of the Forbes 400
in 1981
and assigned me to spend a year traveling around the country and
interviewing wealthy people and those who worked with them about one
another. The most challenging sector was private real estate wealth. My
grandfather had been an accountant to a number of major New York
developers, so I had the advantage of knowing many of the players there.
But the reporting was opaque, because so few of the relevant financial
documents were public; we relied disproportionately on what people told
us. As the project progressed, other experienced reporters and editors
joined what would become the most successful annual special issue in
Forbes history.
From the beginning, Trump was obsessed. The
project could offer a clear, supposedly authoritative declaration of his
status as a player, and while many of the super-rich wanted to keep
their names off the ranking, Trump was desperate to scale it.
[I sold Trump $100,000 worth of pianos. Then he stiffed me.]
When
I first contacted him for the inaugural issue, Trump pulled out all the
stops to convince me that he was the wealthiest real estate developer
in New York. At an afternoon-long meeting in his cavernous Fifth Avenue
office, he argued that his family was worth more than $900 million and
deserved to be higher on our list than any of the far more accomplished
developers (with names like Rose and Rudin) who had spent generations
building top-tier housing in the golden borough of Manhattan. His
father, Fred Trump, was well known for building nearly all the
apartments that the Trump Organization owned before Donald even joined
the company, so it amazed me when Donald claimed that he, and not his
father, possessed 80 percent of the 23,000 apartments he said they had
in Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island. He added that these were almost
debt free and worth $40,000 each.
I questioned his valuation.
Trump shrugged and said, “Okay, then $20,000 each.” That would mean his
family was worth some $500 million, still atop our list for New York
real estate tycoons.
But that figure seemed high. I estimated the
apartments to be worth about $9,000 each: They could not easily be
converted to lucrative co-ops, and Trump had falsely described the
location of the Queens buildings. He’d claimed they were in Forest Hills
when, in fact, they were in the far less valuable Jamaica Estates
neighborhood a few miles away. Since Donald’s new projects were still in
development or unproven, the outer-borough apartments formed the basis
of a Trump family net worth estimate of $200 million.
Six weeks after my initial interview, I received a call at my desk from Trump’s secretary and gatekeeper, Norma Foerderer .
She
said she wanted my work address so Trump could send me an invitation to
a company party. Then she abruptly added: “Oh, Donald was just passing
by! He said that he wanted to have a few words with you.”
Phone conversation between Jonathan Greenberg and Donald Trump on July 15, 1982. (Jonathan Greenberg)
I
switched on my audio recorder — my normal practice — as Trump expressed
his concern for what he called “your little article.” He invited me for
a follow-up interview with him because, he said, he was richer than the
rest. “I don’t think that you have your facts 100 percent correct”
about his standing vis-a-vis other New York developers. I was
contemplating a too-low appraisal of his net worth, he said. “You had us
down in a certain category, and then you mentioned other names, and
there’s no contest, you know. I mean, there’s no contest. So I just
wanted to mention that.”
Trump knew I had doubts about his assertions, so he had his lawyer,
Roy Cohn,
call me. Cohn spent most of his time threatening lawsuits, schmoozing
with mobster clients and badgering reporters with off-the-record
utterances that made his clients look good and their enemies look bad.
Cohn surprised me at my Forbes desk that summer: “Jon Greenberg,” a
scrappy voice bellowed, before I could connect my tape recorder. I took
notes by hand. “This is Roy. Roy Cohn! You can’t quote me! But Donny
tells me you’re putting together this list of rich people. He says
you’ve got him down for just $200 million! That’s way too low, way too
low! Listen, I’m Donny’s personal lawyer, but he said I could talk to
you about this. I am sitting here looking at his current bank statement.
It shows he’s got more than $500 million in liquid assets, just cash.
That’s just Donald, nothing to do with Fred, and it’s just cash.” He
concluded: “He’s worth more than any of those other guys in this town!”
I
offered to have a messenger pick up the bank statement at his office.
Cohn protested that the document was confidential. “Just trust me,” he
said. I told him I wouldn’t take his word without seeing the paperwork.
“It’s confidential!” Cohn yelled.
[I study liars. I’ve never seen one like President Trump.]
My
Forbes editors and I spent many hours deliberating about where to place
Trump. Based on what little we knew — his claims; a 1976 New York Times
profile
that said the Trump Organization owned 22,000 apartments; and Fred’s
reputation for housing a generation of working-class New Yorkers in
Brooklyn and Queens — we ranked Donald and Fred in the bottom tier among
major real-estate developers, each with half of a $200 million
apartment empire.
Even though I learned later that this was far
more money than Donald possessed, it did not satisfy him for the
following year’s edition. During his 1983 interview, Trump claimed that
there were actually 25,000 apartments and that his net worth had
ballooned because of the success of his new projects, Trump Tower and
the Grand Hyatt Hotel on East 42nd Street, as well as a pending casino
deal in Atlantic City.
Then Cohn called again, this time to say
Trump was worth more than $700 million. I recorded our chat. He opened
with an outrageous claim that Trump had personally received $250 million
from the recent sale of a 50 percent interest in his new project to
build a Harrah’s casino in Atlantic City. “A certain amount was cleared,
say, around a hundred million,” Cohn said. “. . . But the balance was
used by him to liquidate certain other things, which made his overall
position very impregnable. Trump Tower has been going like a house
afire, and the profits on that are much higher than had been
anticipated, and the same is true with Grand Hyatt. On top of which he’s
been in a series of private transactions, and he files with banks for
between $700 to $750 million, as well as with Equitable” — Equitable
Life Assurance, the company that financed Trump Tower — “which backs him
in all of his deals.”
Phone conversation between Jonathan Greenberg and Donald Trump's lawyer, Roy Cohn on June 21, 1983. (Jonathan Greenberg)
Again,
Cohn refused to show me a statement, but armed with misinformation
about Trump’s casino payout and claims about cash flow at other
properties, I inflated his (and his father’s) net worth to $200 million
each. In retrospect, Fred Trump was probably worth half that amount, and
Donald, once again, should not have been on the list at all.
The
next year I received two calls from “John Barron,” the fictitious Trump
executive who told me that Donald had taken “in excess of 90 percent”
ownership from Fred. He also suggested that Trump was on track to earn a
$50 million profit every year from his first Atlantic City casino. And
so, in 1984, we increased Donald’s net worth estimate to $400 million
and left Fred in, for his last year on the Forbes 400, at $200 million.
(Barron also bad-mouthed the competition, saying that developer George
Klein had struck a “bad deal” to redevelop Times Square — a bid Trump
had lost — and was “going to go down the tubes.”)
[Trump is calling Comey a liar because to Trump, all criticism is a lie.]
Although
Trump, posing as Barron, asked Forbes to conduct the conversation off
the record, I am publishing it here. I believe an intent to deceive —
both with the made-up persona and the content of the call — released me
from my good-faith pledge. In a 1990 court case, Trump testified that he
had used false names in phone calls to reporters. In 2016, when The
Washington Post published
a similar recording, Trump denied it was him.
Fred
Trump turned down my attempts to interview him for the Forbes 400. He
allowed Donald to say whatever he wanted about the family’s business. In
the only major interview he gave after Donald seized the limelight,
Fred
told
the New York Times in 1983 that “Donald has a competitive spirit and I
don’t want to compete with him. . . . He amazes me. He’s gone way beyond
me, absolutely.”
*** *** *** ***
Eventually, nearly every one of Trump’s pronouncements about his wealth unraveled.
The number of apartments was the first problem. The commonly cited figure — that his family owned 25,000 units —
began
with the mention of 22,000 apartments in that fawning 1976 New York
Times profile. In 1988, after I left Forbes, I counted the units and
found fewer than 8,000. (I was working briefly on a documentary about
Trump that was never completed.) Another Forbes reporter that year, John
Anderson, found the same thing. He called the Trump residential
management organization, he told me then, and asked an executive named
Harry Green how many apartments the company owned. “About 10,000,” Green
told him, meaning that our 1982 family valuation of $200 million should
have been just $90 million (below the cutoff at that time for inclusion
on the list). A few minutes later, Green called Anderson back and
corrected himself: Now there were 25,000 again.
Another brazen
claim was that Trump, not his father, owned the company’s outer-borough
apartments, which his father built beginning in the 1930s. Based on what
Trump said during our 1982 and 1983 interviews, I’d assumed that Donald
and Fred each owned half, resisting the son’s insistence that he had
purchased 80 percent of the units or consolidated the holdings himself.
Still, this comment went into the Forbes 400 records, and in 1985, after
I left the project, Trump was estimated to be worth $600 million, and
his father was off the list.
[Can a president who disregards the truth uphold his oath of office?]
It
would be decades before I learned that Forbes had been conned: In the
early 1980s, Trump had zero equity in his father’s company. According to
Fred’s will (portions of which
appeared in a lawsuit), the father
retained legal ownership of his residential empire until his death in 1999, at which point he left it to be
divided between his
four surviving children
and some of his grandchildren. That explains why, after Trump went
bankrupt in the early 1990s, he borrowed $30 million from his siblings,
secured by an estimated $35 million share of his future inheritance,
according to three sources in Tim O’Brien’s 2005 biography, “
TrumpNation.” He could have used his own assets as collateral if he’d had any worth that amount, but he didn’t.
The
most revelatory document describing Trump’s true net worth in the early
’80s was a 1981 report from the New Jersey Casino Control Commission.
O’Brien obtained a copy for his book. Trump had applied for an Atlantic
City casino license, and regulators were able to review his tax returns
and personal and corporate debt, giving them the most accurate
picture
of his finances. They found that he had an income of about $100,000 a
year, while his 1979 tax returns showed a $3.4 million taxable loss.
Trump’s personal assets consisted of a $1 million trust fund that Fred
Trump provided to each of his children and grandchildren, a few checking
accounts with about $400,000 in them and a 1977 Mercedes 450SL. Nowhere
did the report list an ownership stake in the Trump Organization’s
residential apartments. Trump also possessed a few parcels of valuable
but highly leveraged real estate, financed with $22.5 million in debt,
all of it secured by his father’s assets. He did not own a safe deposit
box or stocks in publicly traded companies. In sum, Trump was worth less
than $5 million, not the $100 million that I reported in the first
Forbes 400.
During our first interview in 1982, Trump informed me
that he had bought the Barbizon Plaza Hotel and the adjoining 110
Central Park West for just $13 million, a steal. While I was in Trump’s
office, a broker supposedly called to offer him $100 million for the
property. Trump refused the offer while looking me in the eye; he
pointed out that his net worth should include an equity boost of $87
million profit. I believed then that he used a staffer to stage the
call, and I resisted the fictitious valuation. But the $13 million price
tag for a valuable parcel was recorded in Forbes 400 files, and it soon
showed up in other publications, such as
New York magazine . It remains on
Wikipedia
today. Yet tucked away on Page 63 of the Casino Commission report was a
section describing Trump’s purchase of the property for $65 million,
facilitated by a $50 million loan to Trump by Chase Manhattan Bank. As
with many of his buildings, Trump’s debt was far higher, and his true
equity far lower, than he claimed.
Roy Cohn had told me that
Trump received $250 million from Holiday Inn for its half-interest in
the Atlantic City casino. But according to O’Brien, Trump’s actual
income from the deal was a construction and management fee (not profit)
of about $24 million, while Holiday Inn financed the construction of the
$220 million casino.
[How do you write political satire when politics are a farce?]
Later
attempts by Trump to paint himself as fantastically wealthy were also
duplicitous. In 1989, Trump sent Forbes journalist Harry Seneker a
statement of his $3.7 billion net worth. I have obtained the letter. It
indicated $900 million in liquid assets. “I am more liquid than any
major developer in the United States,” Trump wrote, inducing the
magazine to increase Trump’s listing from $1 billion in 1988 to $1.7
billion in 1989.
But according to the New Jersey Casino Commission, which issued another
report
in 1991, by the end of 1990 Trump’s entire cash position — in both his
business and personal accounts — was just $19 million. The amount was
insufficient to pay the debt on his over-leveraged casino and real
estate holdings while still covering his personal expenses of $1 million
per month. His net worth, the commission estimated, was $205 million —
less than 6 percent of what he’d told Forbes. In 1990, the magazine
dropped Trump from the list and kept him off it for five years.
Forbes
declined to comment for this article, but its top editor, Randall Lane,
interviewed then-candidate Trump for the Forbes 400 in 2015 and wrote
about the magazine’s long struggle to accurately assess his net worth in
an article titled “
Inside The Epic Fantasy That’s Driven Donald Trump For 33 Years .”
Of the 1,538 tycoons who had been on the “Rich List” through the years,
Lane wrote, “not one has been more fixated with his or her net worth
estimate on a year-in, year-out basis than Donald J. Trump.”
*** *** *** ***
I
was a leading New York real estate reporter through the 1980s. I left
the Forbes staff in 1983 but continued to freelance for the magazine
while writing major investigative features as a contributing editor for
the new Manhattan, Inc. magazine, as well as New York, Avenue and New
York City Business. I knew all the key players. I thought I had a handle
on this material.
But Trump was so competent in conning me that,
until 35 years later, I did not know I had been conned. Instead, I have
gone through my career in national media with a misinformed sense of
satisfaction that, as a perceptive young journalist, I called Trump on
his lies and gave Forbes readers who used the Rich List as a barometer
of private wealth a more accurate picture of his finances than the one
he was selling.
The joke was on me — and everyone else. Trump’s
fabrications provided the basis for a vastly inflated wealth assessment
for the Forbes 400 that would give him cachet for decades as a
triumphant businessman.
In truth, almost nobody had a clear
picture of Trump’s books. In 1990, Trump brought in Steve Bollenbach as a
new chief financial officer to respond to lender concerns about his
crippling debt. “When Bollenbach began delving into the organization’s
finances, he got a surprise,” The Washington Post’s Michael Kranish and
Marc Fisher write in “
Trump Revealed,”
their comprehensive 2016 biography. “The small staff on the
twenty-sixth floor of Trump Tower included three accountants. Each knew
about pieces of the fraying empire — the casinos, for instance, or the
condos. But no one knew the overall picture; there were no consolidated
financial reports.”
In the absence of a functioning balance sheet, the list didn’t just make Trump
feel like
a winner, according to O’Brien; it may have provided some of the
documentation he needed to borrow reckless sums of money — vast loans
that he used, for years, to actually
make him a winner. “The more
often Forbes mentioned him, the more credible Donald’s claim to vast
wealth became,” O’Brien said, arguing that Trump and the list were
“mutually reinforcing”: “The more credible his claim to vast wealth
became, the easier it was for him to get on the Forbes 400 — which
became the standard that other media, and apparently some of the
country’s biggest banks, used when judging Donald’s riches.”
Trump
returned to the Rich List in 1996 with a reported net worth of $450
million and an editor’s note that he claimed to be worth $2 billion. He
never fell off it again. In his book, O’Brien criticized Forbes for
rewarding Trump’s fabrications, citing interviews with “three people
with direct knowledge of Donald’s finances” who estimated his true net
worth after debts to be “somewhere between $150 million and $250
million.” Trump, who had told O’Brien he was worth $6 billion,
sued for libel — and lost. When he lost his appeal in 2011, a New Jersey appellate judge
wrote,
“The largest portion of Mr. Trump’s fortune, according to three people
who had had direct knowledge of his holdings, apparently comes from his
lucrative inheritance. These people estimated that Mr. Trump’s wealth,
presuming that it is not encumbered by heavy debt, may amount to about
$200 million to $300 million. That is an enviably large sum of money by
most people’s standards but far short of the billionaires club.”
The opacity persists. In 2016, Trump’s presidential campaign put out a
statement
saying the candidate had a net worth “in excess of TEN BILLION
DOLLARS.” But he has never released his tax returns, and he has said
that the core Trump Organization asset is the ownership of his brand —
an ineffable marketing claim that is impossible to substantiate or
refute.
STR | AFP | Getty Images
